Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram, is making a significant shift in how advertisers target audiences on its platforms. Meta is phasing out manual targeting from its Advantage+ campaigns and embracing AI-driven automation. Instead of manually selecting audience segments, the system now uses machine learning to handle targeting, placements, and budget optimisation. This update is set to change the way advertising is approached on these platforms.

Overview of Meta’s Update

Meta’s latest update removes manual targeting options from Advantage+ campaigns. Advertisers will no longer choose audiences in the traditional way; instead, the AI optimises the entire process. All new sales, app, and leads campaigns will default to AI-powered optimisation. This change is driven by the need for better performance in an environment of evolving data privacy regulations and reduced tracking capabilities.

The Role of Automation in Marketing

This move is part of a broader industry trend where automation is increasingly taking centre stage. AI-driven optimisation now manages tasks such as targeting, bidding, and budget allocation across various platforms. As a result, marketers are transitioning from hands-on, manual campaign management to a role that focuses on strategy, creative development, and data analysis. Automation is reshaping marketing by making processes more efficient while opening new opportunities for scaling campaigns.

Impact on Advertisers

For experienced advertisers, this update presents both opportunities and challenges. On one hand, AI can uncover nuanced audience segments and continuously optimise campaigns, potentially leading to improved performance and a better return on ad spend. On the other hand, those who have relied on precise, manual targeting may find the loss of granular control challenging. Success in this new environment will depend on providing high-quality data and compelling creative assets to guide the AI effectively.

Pros and Cons of AI-Driven Campaigns

Pros

• Improved Efficiency: Continuous optimisation can lower cost per acquisition and boost overall campaign performance.
• Scalability: With reduced manual intervention, campaigns can quickly scale across diverse audience segments.
• Adaptation to Privacy Changes: AI-driven targeting is better suited to navigate the limitations imposed by stricter data privacy regulations.

Cons

• Reduced Granularity: Losing manual control may hinder highly targeted campaigns that are essential for certain niche audiences.
• Limited Transparency: The decision-making process behind AI targeting can be opaque, making it harder to understand the rationale behind campaign performance.
• Learning Curve: There may be an adjustment period as the algorithm adapts to specific campaign goals and data inputs.
• Reliance on Creative Quality: Broad targeting increases the importance of compelling creative; without it, even well-optimised campaigns may underperform.
• Difficulty Applying Insights: Automated campaigns may offer less insight into audience behaviours, making it harder to translate learnings to other marketing channels.

Meta’s Move in the Broader Paid Media Landscape

Meta’s update is part of a wider shift in the paid media industry. Other platforms are similarly embracing AI to manage and optimise campaigns, reflecting a move away from manual targeting toward systems that can dynamically adjust strategies based on real-time data. This trend indicates that the future of digital advertising will increasingly rely on a combination of advanced automation and strategic human oversight.

My Experience with Advantage+ Campaigns

In my own testing, I have found that Advantage+ works exceptionally well for eCommerce campaigns, streamlining processes and delivering efficient results. However, when I applied the same approach to music streaming campaigns for music artists, the outcomes were different. While the system generated a high volume of leads when driving users to Spotify, the quality of these leads was lacking. Many users visited the artist profile without taking further action, such as following the act. When I switched back to manual campaigns, there were fewer conversions overall, but the engagement quality was significantly higher—users were more likely to follow the band and add tracks to their playlists. This experience underscores the importance of tailoring campaign strategies to the specific goals and audience dynamics of different industries.

Conclusion

Meta’s decision to phase out manual targeting from Advantage+ campaigns marks a turning point in digital advertising. While the update reduces direct control over audience selection, it offers the promise of improved efficiency, scalability, and better adaptation to current privacy challenges. For experienced marketers, the key to success lies in blending AI-driven automation with strategic oversight—ensuring that quality data and creative excellence continue to drive results in the evolving landscape of paid media.

‍